I would like your advice, Peeps.
Not too too long ago, we tried potty training for a weekend. The pee part went fine and dandy, but the poo part was very traumatizing for all of us. Wallace went from not wanting to poop on the potty to being terrified to poop on the potty all the way to being terrified for 24 hours to poop anywhere. That was not the goal we were aiming for, so we pretty much abandoned training.
For the past month, Wallace has continued to pee on the potty around diaper change times, in the morning and evening and before his bath. He’s been doing that reliably for about seven months, so it’s not at all traumatic. However, any attempt to poop on the potty sent him into a murderous rage for the rest of the day. The very idea of pooping on the potty seemed to offend him down to his toes. So we didn’t insist. He was ready, but disinclined to acquiescse to our request, so we stopped requesting.
Two mornings ago, when he pooped on the potty, he took himself off to do it. His dad didn’t insist or ask; nobody nudged him; he just took himself off and did it. He seemed initially thrilled by all the hoorays he received, but since that time he has been a roiling mass of misery.
Nothing is good enough, all answers are wrong. He’s hitting and kicking and sad and pouty and whiney and miserable. Nothing cheers him up for more than five minutes at a stretch and he wakes up this way. What it looks like to me, although I’m no child psychologist, is that he’s seriously uncomfortable with going on the potty and what it means. He doesn’t want to grow up.
Beyond the obvious exhaustion we’re all feeling dealing with a screaming, fitting, suddenly out-of-character hitting kid, it breaks my heart to watch him fight something so bitterly that is so inevitable. He doesn’t want to grow up, but his little body and brain aren’t with the program and they continue to mature even as he fights it.
My question to you, as professional People with Opinions, is what tack we should take as parents of a miserable potty-ready child who does not want to be a potty-ready child. Do we just hang with him during this hard time and keep going with the diapers until he settles into something more comfortable? Or, do we do a big potty-training weekend this weekend and just bite the bullet and alter reality until underpants and potties are the norm rather than the exception?
My instinct is that he needs help. His reaction to using the potty hasn’t changed in two months. He’s making physical progress, but not emotional progress, and he seems to be stuck in a rut that he can’t get out of. My instinct is to just get rid of the diapers, go for the gusto, and work through the drama until the change is accepted. I’m afraid that by letting his initial freakout to pooping stand, we’ve confirmed in his mind that it’s a big horrible thing. Maybe it’s like insisting he get back on his bike after falling off. No big deal, you just get up and ride again, Tanto.
At the same time, I’d like to give him a helpful boost to the next developmental level, not toss him over the edge of a miserable abyss against his will.
Help! What would you do?
Permalink